This City Has Been Named the Murder Capital of Missouri

St. Louis, renowned as the historic Gateway City to the West, has garnered an unfortunate reputation as the murder capital of Missouri. With an alarming homicide rate exceeding 70 murders per 100,000 people, St. Louis stands out as one of the most violent cities in America and is considered among the world’s most perilous. This prompts the question: What factors have contributed to the city’s distressing decline, and what measures can be taken to reverse it?

The Historical Trajectory of St. Louis

Founded in 1764 as a fur-trading post by a French explorer and named after Louis IX of France, St. Louis became part of the United States in 1803 through the Louisiana Purchase. Evolving into a thriving river port and industrial hub, the city attracted immigrants from Europe and African Americans seeking economic opportunities. St. Louis showcased its cultural and civic achievements by hosting the World’s Fair and the summer Olympics in 1904.

Despite these successes, the city grappled with challenges such as racial discrimination, segregation, and urban decay. The impact of the Civil War, the Great Depression, and the World Wars took a toll on both the economy and social fabric. The postwar era witnessed a substantial exodus of residents and businesses to surrounding counties due to the rise of automobiles and suburbanization. The city’s population peaked at 856,796 in 1950 but dwindled to 300,576 in 2019—a 65 percent loss.

Depopulation and disinvestment led to the deterioration of the city’s tax base, infrastructure, and public services. Poverty, unemployment, crime, and corruption became prevalent issues, culminating in racial tensions that erupted in 2014 with the fatal shooting of Michael Brown, an unarmed black teenager, by a white police officer in the suburb of Ferguson. This incident sparked national debates on police brutality and racial justice.

St. Louis’s Current State of Crisis

St. Louis currently grapples with a crisis in public order and safety. In 2020, the city recorded 267 murders, the highest since 1993, with a murder rate of 87.2 per 100,000 people—the highest among U.S. cities with populations exceeding 100,000. Other violent crimes, including robbery, assault, rape, and carjacking, also saw elevated rates. The majority of both victims and perpetrators are young black men, disproportionately affected by the city’s social and economic challenges.

Law enforcement and the criminal justice system are strained and under-resourced. The St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department faces shortages in officers, equipment, and training, drawing criticism for its use of force, lack of accountability, and low homicide clearance rate. St. Louis Circuit Attorney Kimberly Gardner has been accused of being soft on crime and mishandling cases, further straining the relationship between the police and the prosecutor.

Elected leaders, including Mayor Lyda Krewson, have been perceived as ineffective, especially in the aftermath of the 2020 George Floyd protests, marked by looting, arson, and shootings. The divided city council struggles to agree on a coherent strategy to combat crime, contributing to residents’ loss of faith in their government and their future.

A Path Forward for St. Louis

While facing significant challenges, St. Louis is not without hope. Leveraging its rich history, culture, architecture, diverse and educated population, as well as a network of universities, hospitals, and nonprofits, the city can attract tourists and investors. To reverse the tide of violence and decline, St. Louis requires a comprehensive and collaborative approach involving all sectors of society.

Investments in human and physical capital, coupled with initiatives to create more jobs, housing, and amenities, are crucial. Reforming the law enforcement and criminal justice system to enhance capacity, accountability, and legitimacy is imperative. Fostering a culture of peace and inclusion, promoting dialogue, reconciliation, and mutual respect among diverse communities, will contribute to the city’s revitalization.

Although labeled the murder capital of Missouri, St. Louis can reclaim its status as the Gateway to the West—a symbol of progress and prosperity. With concerted efforts, the city has the potential to overcome challenges, becoming a safe and vibrant place to live, work, and visit. A comeback for St. Louis is indeed possible.


New Jersey Named America’s Most Corrupt City, Again

Leave a Comment