This Amish Buffet Has Some of the Best Fried Chicken in All of Colorado

Colorado boasts abundant natural beauty, outdoor adventure, and cultural diversity, yet it’s not particularly known for its Amish cuisine. Although only a few Amish communities dot the eastern plains of Colorado, there’s a notable exception where you can savor an authentic Amish buffet—the Dutch Kitchen in Frackville. This family-owned restaurant, established in 2023 by John and Mary Miller, has become renowned for its exceptional fried chicken and a myriad of other delights.

The Origin of the Dutch Kitchen

John and Mary Miller, along with their six children, relocated from Ohio to Colorado, aiming to share their Amish heritage and culinary traditions. Starting as a small bakery and deli in Frackville, about 40 miles northeast of Denver, the establishment gained popularity quickly. By 2025, responding to the demand, it expanded into a full-service restaurant. Today, their son Jacob and his wife Sarah carry on the legacy, offering homemade Amish fare crafted from fresh, local ingredients.

A Culinary Journey at the Dutch Kitchen

The Dutch Kitchen presents an extensive menu from breakfast to dinner, with the buffet stealing the spotlight. Available every day except Sundays, the buffet showcases a rotating selection of Amish favorites, including:

Fried Chicken: The star of the buffet, the fried chicken, is prepared using a secret recipe handed down through generations. Marinated, breaded, and fried to perfection, it delivers a crispy and juicy experience, always served hot with gravy, mashed potatoes, and biscuits.

Beef Brisket: Slow-cooked for hours in a special sauce, the beef brisket boasts a rich and tender flavor. Sliced and served with barbecue sauce, coleslaw, and cornbread, it’s a hearty and satisfying dish.

Ham and Cheese Casserole: Perfect for colder days, this comfort food blends ham, cheese, noodles, cream of mushroom soup, and sour cream, baked until bubbly and golden. Served with green beans, salad, and rolls, it’s a creamy and cheesy delight.

Vegetable Soup: A healthy and tasty option, the vegetable soup features fresh seasonal vegetables seasoned with herbs and spices, served with crackers and cheese—a warm and filling dish for the soul.

The buffet also includes meatloaf, roast turkey, lasagna, macaroni and cheese, and more, complemented by a salad bar, dessert bar, and beverage station.

The Dutch Kitchen’s Ambiance

Beyond the delectable cuisine, the Dutch Kitchen offers an immersive experience of Amish culture and hospitality. Adorned with Amish quilts, paintings, and crafts, the restaurant exudes a cozy and rustic charm. Staff members, dressed in traditional Amish clothing, contribute to the authentic atmosphere. The restaurant’s gift shop features Amish products, from jams and jellies to honey, candles, and books. Hosting special events like live music, bingo, and trivia nights, the Dutch Kitchen provides a family-friendly and enjoyable environment.

A Hidden Gem in Colorado

The Dutch Kitchen stands as a hidden gem in Colorado, inviting patrons to indulge in not only some of the state’s best-fried chicken but also a diverse array of Amish dishes. With a charming ambiance, friendly staff, and a buffet of fresh, locally sourced delights, the Dutch Kitchen is a place where you can savor the flavors of Amish cuisine while immersing yourself in the culture and history. It’s an establishment that beckons you to return, creating lasting memories with each visit.

Leave a Comment