Most people would say New York City holds the crown as North America’s priciest place to call home. Towering skyscrapers, eye-watering rents, fifteen-dollar cocktails. It all checks out, right? Here’s the thing, though. There’s actually a tiny island territory sitting in the Atlantic that makes even Manhattan look like a bargain. We’re talking about Hamilton, Bermuda.
Yeah, you read that correctly. This picturesque British Overseas Territory, with its pink sand beaches and pastel-colored houses, consistently outranks every major North American city when it comes to cost of living. Let’s dive into why this tropical paradise comes with such a hefty price tag.
Where Exactly Is Bermuda, Anyway
Before we get into the numbers, let’s clear up some geography confusion. Bermuda is a British Overseas Territory 900 miles north of the Caribbean, 600 miles east of North Carolina. Technically speaking, it’s considered part of North America, even though it’s not connected to the mainland.
The capital city, Hamilton, sits on the main island and serves as the financial and commercial hub. Its population of 854 (2016) and its small land area make it one of the smallest capital cities in the world. Small doesn’t mean cheap, though. Far from it!
The Numbers Don’t Lie About Bermuda’s Costs
Let’s get straight to the hard facts. Using an index in which New York is scored at 100, Bermuda was scored at 126.34. That means living in Bermuda costs more than a quarter higher than in New York City, which itself is notoriously expensive.
Bermuda topped the list with a score of 126.34, followed by Switzerland with 90.68, showing just how far ahead Bermuda is compared to other expensive destinations. Switzerland, famous for its high costs, doesn’t even come close.
More recent comparative data show the gap narrowing slightly but remaining significant. The cost of living in New York City is 17% more expensive than in Hamilton, Bermuda, according to some 2025 calculations, though other sources show them nearly equal. The discrepancy depends on methodology, but the key takeaway remains unchanged. Bermuda consistently ranks among the most expensive places to live.
- Cost of Living Index (NYC = 100): Bermuda 126.34
- Global Ranking: 48th most expensive city out of 9,294 worldwide
- Average Monthly Cost: $3,392 for a single person (excluding rent)
- Salary Coverage: Median after-tax salary covers only 1.8 months of expenses
Why Your Grocery Bill Will Shock You
The cost of groceries here is 46% higher than in New York City. Imagine paying almost half again as much for your milk, bread, and eggs. That morning coffee ritual? It’s going to hurt your wallet.
99% of all Bermuda’s foods, goods, and other consumer products are imported. The island produces almost nothing locally, so everything arrives by ship or plane from the United States or elsewhere. Those transportation costs get passed directly to consumers.
I know it sounds crazy, but even basics become luxury items here. In Hamilton, it was listed as being $16.40 for the same amount for $4.49 in San Francisco for milk, according to one comparison. Nearly four times the price for the same product.
Typical Grocery Costs in Bermuda:
- 2-liter Coca-Cola: $6
- Basic food items: 5-15% import duty
- Sauces and condiments: 15% import duty
- Beer: $0.99 per liter duty (no duty-free allowance)
Housing Costs That Make Manhattan Look Reasonable
Rent prices in Bermuda reach staggering heights. An average one-bedroom apartment rent would be $3,300 per month in a place like Hamilton, $2,200 outside Hamilton. A two-bedroom? You’re looking at $4,000 monthly in Hamilton.
Property ownership comes with its own nightmares. Annual property taxes for non-Bermudians are among the highest in the world, sometimes in excess of $80,000 pa, compared to £1,600 sterling in central London, England. Fifty times more than central London’s property tax? That’s genuinely shocking.
Average house rent in Bermuda is 15% lower than in New York City, according to some indices, but this is misleading since other costs more than compensate. The overall picture remains extremely expensive.
Rental Market Snapshot (2025):
- 1-Bedroom (Hamilton): $2,500-$3,500/month
- 2-Bedroom (Hamilton): $3,500-$4,000/month
- 3-Bedroom (Hamilton): $6,300/month
- Luxury waterfront: $16,000+/month
- Property tax (non-Bermudians): Up to $80,000/year
Dining Out Costs More Than You’d Believe
Restaurant prices tell another painful story. Bermuda’s restaurant price index is 52% higher than NYC. Every meal out becomes a significant expense, whether it’s lunch at a casual spot or dinner somewhere nice.
Even grabbing a beer requires careful budgeting. At $9 a beer, you’ll need a few more to forget about the damage to your wallet in Hamilton, according to one tourism site. Nine dollars for a single beer is pretty steep by any standard.
Dining Price Points:
- Restaurant Index: 52% higher than NYC
- Beer (draft): ~$9
- Moderate dinner: $50+ per person
- Business lunch: Significantly above US standards
Import Duties Make Everything Worse
Here’s where things get particularly brutal. Import duties are the second-biggest cause of Government income after payroll taxes, and residents pay about 300 to 500 percent higher import duties overall than in the USA, Canada, and the United Kingdom.
Your duty-free allowance is reportedly only around US or BDA $200 per person per month, making it by far the least generous place in the Northern and Eastern hemispheres in terms of import duty allowances. Bring home more than that modest amount, and you’ll pay roughly 35 percent on the excess value.
These duties ripple through the entire economy. Everything from clothing to electronics to household goods carries these additional costs, compounding the expense of daily life.
Import Duty Breakdown:
- Average duty rate: 22.5% on most goods
- Standard personal items: 25% duty
- Electronics/appliances: 33.4%
- Furniture/sporting goods: 22.25%
- Automobiles: 75% on the first $10,000, then 150%
- Duty-free allowance: Only $200/person/month
- Essential medicines & books: 0% duty
Your Salary Won’t Go As Far Here
Even with higher average wages, purchasing power takes a hit. The average salary in Bermuda covers 22% less goods and services within Bermuda compared to what an average salary in NYC would cover within New York City. You earn more, sure, but you can afford less.
This creates a strange economic reality where even professionals with good incomes struggle to maintain comfortable lifestyles. The high wages that initially look attractive get eaten up by the relentless costs of everything from utilities to transportation.
How Bermuda Compares to Other Major North American Cities
Let’s put this in a broader context. New York City remains the most expensive city within the United States proper, followed by Los Angeles, Honolulu, San Francisco, and Nassau, Bahamas, according to major cost-of-living rankings.
Cost of living in Hamilton, Bermuda, is 48% more expensive than in Toronto, Canada’s largest and most expensive city. Cost of living in Hamilton, Bermuda is reportedly 13% more expensive than in Honolulu, Hawaii, another notoriously pricey island destination.
The pattern holds across virtually every comparison. Hamilton consistently outranks mainland North American cities, sometimes by enormous margins. Only when compared directly to Manhattan do the numbers get close, and even then, Bermuda often edges ahead depending on which metrics you emphasize.
North America Cost Comparison (vs Hamilton, Bermuda):
| City | % More Expensive Than Hamilton |
|---|---|
| Toronto, Canada | 48% cheaper |
| Honolulu, Hawaii | 14% cheaper |
| Miami, Florida | 10% cheaper |
| Chicago, Illinois | 18% cheaper |
| New York City | About the same to 17% more expensive* |
*Varies by methodology and year
Why Does Bermuda Cost So Much
The reasons behind Bermuda’s astronomical costs are actually pretty straightforward. It’s a tiny island with limited space and resources. You have over 3,000 persons per square mile, making it one of the most densely populated places on Earth.
Nearly everything needs importing across hundreds of miles of ocean. There’s no domestic agriculture to speak of, no manufacturing base, no natural resources to exploit. The island runs on tourism and international finance, both of which support high wages but also drive up demand for limited housing and services.
Government policies compound these natural disadvantages. High import duties fund government operations in lieu of income taxes, but they also inflate consumer prices dramatically. Strict property ownership rules limit housing supply and push prices skyward.
Key Cost Drivers:
- 99% import dependency – Almost nothing is produced locally
- Geographic isolation – 600+ miles from nearest mainland
- High population density – 3,000+ people per square mile
- Government revenue model – Import duties instead of income tax
- Limited land availability – Only 21 square miles total
- No de minimis threshold – Duty charged on ALL imports
The Bottom Line on Bermuda’s Sky-High Costs
So there you have it. In 2021, Bermuda topped the world’s Cost of Living Index, becoming the most expensive country in the world to live in, a position it has frequently held. Among North American locations specifically, nothing else comes close.
The combination of extreme geographic isolation, total import dependence, limited land area, high population density, and government policies creates a perfect storm of expense. Every single category, from groceries to rent to dining, costs significantly more than comparable mainland cities.
Next time someone complains about New York City prices, you might want to mention Hamilton, Bermuda. It puts things in perspective. Sometimes paradise comes with a price tag that even Wall Street bankers would find shocking. What would you be willing to pay to live on a beautiful island? Tell us in the comments.
Final Reality Check:
- World Bank estimate: 3-4x more expensive than the US overall
- Recommended for: High earners ($160k+), remote workers, finance professionals
- Main challenges: Healthcare costs, limited shopping, and extreme import dependency
- Population: ~3,700 in Hamilton proper; 65,000 island-wide
- Economic base: International business (insurance/reinsurance) and tourism
<p>The post The Most Expensive Place to Live in North America Is Actually an Island first appeared on Travelbinger.</p>